Alibi Hour

Solved cases

Alibi Hour #36: The Missing Trophy

A medium whodunit logic puzzle from Thursday, November 5, 2026. The gold debate trophy vanished from the Trophy Hall. The display case alarm chirped once at 7:30 PM. Four suspects, one liar, six ten-minute times from 7:00 to 7:50 PM. The case has closed, so the full case file, all 24 statements and the solution are below; par was 4 questions.

The case file

Case #36 · Thu, Nov 5 · medium

Awards night at Maple Ridge High is over, and the building is nearly empty.

The gold debate trophy vanished from the Trophy Hall. The display case alarm chirped once at 7:30 PM.

  • Devstudent council treasurer
  • Esmeband director
  • Samcoach
  • Wrenyearbook editor

Gym and Trophy Hall are side by side on top, Music Room and Cafeteria below them; Gym is diagonally across from Cafeteria, and Trophy Hall from Music Room. The scene is the Trophy Hall, and the incident happened at 7:30 PM.

The suspects: Dev, the student council treasurer; Esme, the band director; Sam, the coach; and Wren, the yearbook editor.

The rules

One of the four suspects is the culprit and lies in every answer; the other three always tell the truth. The culprit was alone in the scene at the time of the incident. In ten minutes a person can stay put or walk to a room next door; the room diagonally across takes twenty minutes.

Every statement

In the game you have 10 questions and see only the answers you ask for. Here are all 24. Can you find the liar, and which 4 statements prove it? The solution is further down.

Dev, the student council treasurer

  • “At 7:00 I was in the Gym.”
  • “At 7:10 I was in the Trophy Hall.”
  • “At 7:20 I was in the Trophy Hall.”
  • “At 7:30 I was alone in the Cafeteria.”
  • “At 7:40 I was in the Trophy Hall.”
  • “At 7:50 I was in the Trophy Hall.”

Esme, the band director

  • “At 7:00 I was in the Trophy Hall.”
  • “At 7:10 I was in the Gym.”
  • “At 7:20 I was in the Gym.”
  • “At 7:30 I was in the Gym.”
  • “At 7:40 I was in the Music Room with Sam.”
  • “At 7:50 I was in the Cafeteria.”

Sam, the coach

  • “At 7:00 I was in the Cafeteria.”
  • “At 7:10 I was in the Music Room with Wren.”
  • “At 7:20 I was alone in the Cafeteria.”
  • “At 7:30 I was in the Music Room.”
  • “At 7:40 I was in the Music Room.”
  • “At 7:50 I was in the Music Room.”

Wren, the yearbook editor

  • “At 7:00 I was in the Gym with Dev.”
  • “At 7:10 I was in the Music Room with Sam.”
  • “At 7:20 I was in the Music Room.”
  • “At 7:30 I was alone in the Gym.”
  • “At 7:40 I was in the Trophy Hall with Esme.”
  • “At 7:50 I was in the Trophy Hall with Dev.”

The solution

Show who did it

The culprit was Esme, the band director. Esme was alone in the Trophy Hall at 7:30, and all six of Esme's statements are false; the other three suspects told the truth every time.

The shortest proof: 4 questions

These answers, taken together, leave only Esme as a possible liar:

  1. Dev about 7:00: “At 7:00 I was in the Gym.”
  2. Sam about 7:10: “At 7:10 I was in the Music Room with Wren.”
  3. Wren about 7:00: “At 7:00 I was in the Gym with Dev.”
  4. Wren about 7:10: “At 7:10 I was in the Music Room with Sam.”

Why not the others

  • Not Dev. If Dev were the liar, these couldn't all hold:
    • Dev at 7:00: “At 7:00 I was in the Gym.”
    • Wren at 7:00: “At 7:00 I was in the Gym with Dev.”
  • Not Sam. If Sam were the liar, these couldn't all hold:
    • Sam at 7:10: “At 7:10 I was in the Music Room with Wren.”
    • Wren at 7:10: “At 7:10 I was in the Music Room with Sam.”
  • Not Wren. If Wren were the liar, these couldn't all hold:
    • Sam at 7:10: “At 7:10 I was in the Music Room with Wren.”
    • Wren at 7:10: “At 7:10 I was in the Music Room with Sam.”

Where everyone really was

Suspect7:007:107:207:307:407:50
DevGymTrophy HallTrophy HallCafeteriaTrophy HallTrophy Hall
Esme (culprit)GymTrophy HallTrophy HallTrophy Hall ⚑Trophy HallTrophy Hall
SamCafeteriaMusic RoomCafeteriaMusic RoomMusic RoomMusic Room
WrenGymMusic RoomMusic RoomGymTrophy HallTrophy Hall

Times are PM. ⚑ marks the scene at the minute of the incident: only the culprit was there.

Play today's case

A new Alibi Hour case opens for everyone at 00:00 UTC, and it runs in ChatGPT. Say “Let's play today's Alibi Hour case”, or “Use Alibi Hour to show me case #36's solution” to see this one in the card.

← #35: The Snow Globe · All solved cases · #37: The Robot's Missing Chip →

New to one-liar puzzles? How to solve a one-liar logic puzzle walks through the method.